Are you craving something sweet while walking down the magnificent beaches of Anna Maria Island? Top Florida’s warm sunny weather with ice cream, chocolate brownies, decadent cakes, and pastries. Satisfy your sweet tooth and check out these top-rated dessert shops on Anna Maria Island.

4 Can’t-Miss Dessert Shops on Anna Maria Island

Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery

9801 Gulf Dr. – (941) 896-5308

This family-owned dessert shop sits at the top of Anna Maria Island, with a delightful selection of desserts and pastries. They have flavors like mint chip, chocolate raspberry, and toasted coconut. Fill in your taste buds with their original homemade Italian gelato from fresh fruits.

Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery’s specialties are to die for! Try their specialties, including danishes, croissants, the famous William Dean truffles, and other fresh-baked pastries.

Dips Ice Cream

503 Pine Ave. – (941) 778-1706

Are you looking for the best ice cream spot on AMI? Beat the heat with their tasty ice cream with various flavors and toppings available. Every scoop of Dips Ice Cream will leave you coming back for more.

Their homemade ice cream is a fan-favorite of most visitors, and it’s no surprise when people keep returning. If you’re a sports fan, their sports memorabilia and baseball card collection inside the shop are worth a look!

Two Scoops

101 S. Bay Blvd. – (941) 779-2422

Two Scoops, another popular ice cream spot on AMI, offers a wide selection of flavors and waffle cone options. They have over 30 flavors, including Coffee Crunch, PnB Fudge, and Lemon Sorbet, all equally addicting and satisfying. 

Aside from ice cream, they also serve breakfast and lunch. From Fried Egg Sandwiches and Belgian Waffles to BLTs and Big Grilled Cheese, you’ll find something tasty to satisfy your appetite. You can also create your own sandwich with your choice of meats and spreads.

Hometown Desserts

507 Pine Ave. – (941) 896-3167

Hometown Desserts is a 5-star rated dessert shop in AMI, known for its savory cakes and coffee. They have the perfect menu for cakes, pies, cheesecakes, cupcakes, cookies, and scones. You name it, and they have it!

Make sure to get a slice of their famous Coconut Key Lime Cake that’s oozing with flavor in every bite. Want to share their delicious desserts with someone or give it as a birthday gift? No problem! Hometown Desserts can create personalized or custom cakes and desserts according to your taste.

Anna Maria Island’s #1 Shop for Beach Supply Rentals

Kick off your Anna Maria Island getaway with the most exciting activities and start your family adventure. Need to rent gear? No problem, Fun and More Rentals have got you covered! We have everything you need, from golf carts and bike rentals to kayaks and paddle boards.

Thanks for visiting. Contact us and book now!