If you’re looking for the freshest seafood on Anna Maria Island, you’re in for a treat. This charming island on Florida’s Gulf Coast is a seafood haven. To help you navigate the seafood scene, we’ve curated a list of the five best seafood markets around Anna Maria Island.
Seafood Market Anna Maria Island: 5 Best Spots to Grab the Freshest Catch
1. Topsail Steamer
5321 Gulf Dr., Holmes Beach – (941) 254-6060
Topsail Steamer offers a unique twist to the seafood game. With the slogan “Take home, steam, and eat,” this market lets you assemble your own customized seafood boil. Choose from a variety of fresh options, add spices, sauces, and sides, and take it home to steam to perfection. If DIY isn’t your thing, Topsail Steamer also offers preassembled buckets. It is a great place for seafood lovers on AMI.
Check our showcased review of Topsail Steamer:
“Topsail Steamer’s seafood is so fresh and flavorful. It made our normal meal taste like a fancy restaurant meal. And the best part is they do all the hard work for you! All you have to do is cook it up and enjoy it. I will definitely order from them again!” – L.K., 5 Stars
2. Captain Anthony’s Stone Crab Store
107 Spring Ave, Anna Maria – (941) 807-0071
Captain Anthony’s Stone Crab Store is your go-to spot for the freshest stone crabs on Anna Maria Island. Founded by a local legend, Captain Anthony Manali, this market supplies many of the island’s seafood restaurants.
Visit for abundant fresh stone crabs, especially during peak season (October to May). Captain Anthony personally lays the traps to ensure they have the freshest catch. They also offer homemade sauces like the famous mustard sauce and Mullet fish dip to enhance your seafood experience.
3. Island Fresh Market
5604 Marina Dr Suite A, Holmes Beach – (941) 567-6130
At Island Fresh Market, locals and visitors love their fresh seafood and local goodies. It’s the best spot for island groceries, offering fresh fish, tasty sandwiches, and other options. They also have gourmet soups and picnic must-haves.
4. Star Fish Company
12306 46th Ave W, Cortez – (941) 794-124
Founded in the early 20s and now owned by Karen Bell, Star Fish Company in Cortez Village is a seafood paradise. Boasting a retail market with the best selection of freshly caught fish, it goes beyond a dockside restaurant.
Their seafood market has everything you can think of—from fresh grouper, snapper, and mullet to tasty shrimp, stone crabs, and oysters. At their restaurant, they cook the most delicious meals using the simplest techniques— fried, grilled, blackened, or sauteed.
5. Cortez Bait & Seafood Company
12110 Cortez Rd., Cortez – (941) 794-1547
Popularly known as Cortez Fish Market, this is another go-to spot for fresh seafood near AMI. They have the best selection of freshly caught fish like mahi mahi, mullet, pompano, swordfish, and tigerfish. You’ll also find top-quality pink shrimp, jumbo gulf shrimp, clams, mussels, stone crabs, and more.
Don’t miss their assortment of spices and seasonings to complement your seafood feast.
Hungry for a seafood adventure?
What are you waiting for? Start exploring the best seafood markets around Anna Maria Island today. You won’t be disappointed!
Anna Maria Island’s #1 Shop for Beach Supply Rentals
Kick off your Anna Maria Island getaway with the most exciting activities to start your family adventure. Fun and More Rentals has your beach supply needs covered! We have everything you need, from golf carts and bike rentals to kayaks and paddle boards. Contact us and book now!
Thanks for visiting!
